Below is a post from the blog of a woman who calls herself Madam Noire – I found her piece interesting, even if I didn’t wholly agree with it. It was a good read. I forwarded it to my husband, whose brilliant response can be found below Madam Noire’s blog post. Gotta love a good Disney Princess debate!
Madame Noire | Black Women's Lifestyle Guide | Black Hair | Black Love
From the time I was a year old Cinderella was my favorite Disney princess. This was the Golden Books story version, not the movie. The way my parents relayed the story, Cinderella and the Prince danced round and around and around.For some reason, as a baby, I liked that image.
Then as I got older and started watching the movie I identified with the fact that she was able to escape a very bad situation and live happily ever after. I wasn’t living in a bad situation but the story was universal. Cinderella made it out and I could respect that. As a kid that’s all I took from the story.
It wasn’t until I got older, like during my preteen days, that I started to realize my girl Cinderella and all of her Disney princess friends weren’t sending the most realistic messages about life and love. I started to notice that for many of the princesses their entire existence centered around being beautiful and getting a man. That’s what they sang about, dreamed about and in some of their cases, struggled to obtain. You can see what I’m talking about in this illustration below:
Now, there’s nothing wrong with wanting to be beautiful, finding a man and living happily ever after. As little girls we all wanted to be considered beautiful and live in some fantasy land with our latest elementary school crush. The problem comes in when you focus every fiber of your being on snagging the man. Becoming so consumed with him that you forget to nurture your passions and talents. The above illustration represents some gross exaggerations. I sincerely doubt little girls were cognizant of these messages. (With the exception of Ariel from “The Little Mermaid,” even as a child I recognized the fact that baby girl had to give up everything to get the man). But that’s not the point. As little girls it takes time for us to understand the concept of self fulfillment, balancing a relationship and achieving your own goals. That doesn’t come until much later.
But that doesn’t mean it’s not a concept Disney couldn’t utilize in their lucrative movie-making empire to promote. Thankfully, somewhere along the line somebody at Disney realized this.
You want to know how I know? Two words.
Princess Tiana.
Now The Princess and the Frog wasn’t perfect but aside from the fact that she was a black woman, Princess Tiana was different from any of the other Disney princesses. Tiana had a dream, an empowering one at that. While she was gifted with the pretty domestic ability of being a good cook, Tiana wanted to own a restaurant. And while the other princesses were working toward getting the man, Tiana was working to get her restaurant. And I mean working hard. I’m not embarrassed to say that I was invested in her character. Watching her work tirelessly only to save a few pennies at the end of the day had me exhausted.
But at the conclusion of the movie what I dug about Tiana’s character was the fact that she brought something to the table. In fact, she had more on the ball than the Prince she would eventually marry. So much so that she taught him a thing or two about work ethic and drive. And he taught her something about taking time to enjoy life. Reciprocal relationships. Now that’s a story I can relate to.
And while little ones might not experience the movie on that level, please believe they notice how hard Princess Tiana worked for her dream and how her work eventually paid off. That’s a lesson little girls need to learn and I’m happy they received that lesson from Disney’s first black princess.
Getting your dream and the man. That’s the perfect definition of Happily Ever After.
I disagree with this woman being so harsh about the other princesses.
Princess Jasmine
She wasn't interested in a man; she was interested in getting out into the world. She didn't like being a princess, she didn't like men (in general ‘cause she was being set up). She just wanted to experience life which she couldn't do while she was in the kingdom. So she left, met someone that she just clicked with, mainly ‘cause he saved her and showed her a different life.
Even when "Prince Ali" came to get her, she still wasn't interested until he offered her a carpet ride because I think it sort of half clicked with her that Prince Ali might be Aladdin (‘cause he said "trust me" and she said "what did you say?"). It was the adventure she fell in love with probably more than Prince Ali.
So I think she's wrong here...
Belle
I think she's a bit harsh on Belle. Belle is a super intelligent woman who wasn't really interested in the beast but the more time she spent with him she realised he wasn't that bad, plus she was kind of helping him being better etc. so she improved his life. If she'd ended up with Gaston, then fair enough with those comments, but she didn't. She went with the ugly beast who turned into a yucky man. Yes she was beautiful and everything but who cares? That's just who she was. Was she not showing that beautiful people can be intelligent too? She didn't exactly dress all princessy prior to getting that lovely yellow dress Sienna loves so much (we all love so much). Leave Belle alone!
Ariel
I don’t know anything about this story
Aurora / Cinderella / snow white /
Aurora was happy living her life with her fairies and her animals. Yeah she probably cared a little about boys, but she'd never met any. She sang songs about dreams she had etc but i think it was probably just the shock of actually meeting a boy who was nice etc that made her like him. (It’s a bit funny ‘cause if she'd never met a boy, how would she know to dream of one? or what they'd look like? hmmm. maybe the fairies played dress ups.)
Cinderella just really wanted to escape from her world. Her step mother and step sisters were really mean to her so she wanted to escape. She knew her dad was a wonderful man and she missed him and so when there was a chance to escape with the prince she was very excited. It’s not her fault.
Snow white is crap.
In general, what she says about these is sort of true I guess. But that was the time these movies were made, they were all 50s or thereabouts, that's how the world was, that's what girls wanted until the world modernised and people became smarter and there were more things to interest girls.
With the later Disney films, like the Beasts, Aladdins etc, I think Disney have realised the world has changed and so their movies are changing also, becoming less simple and man dreamy and giving the female characters a lot more character.
Thanks Pete, you're awesome!
P.S. Watched 'The Frog and the Princess' yesterday and I have to agree with Madame Noire - it was a great movie, which sent a more positive message to little viewers than most of the Disney Princesses do! But as Pete said, that's because they're moving with the times. Princess Tiana rules!